Bensonhurst Italian Restaurants: Tommaso and Spumoni Gardens
Tony Marchetti · November 15, 2026 · 7 min read
The only Bensonhurst Italian restaurant in this guide whose site lists it open all seven days is L&B Spumoni Gardens at 2725 86th Street, 11:00 AM to 11:30 PM, and its menu prints dollar prices such as a $25.95 chicken entrée and a $35.00 Sicilian Pie. Tommaso at 6916 18th Avenue prints its menu figures without dollar signs, Da Vinci Pizzeria at 6514 18th Avenue posts no hours, and Gargiulo’s at 2911 West 15th Street is in Coney Island, included as a labeled outlier. Hours, prices and policies below come from each restaurant’s own website, checked in October 2026.
Bensonhurst Italian restaurants: what each one prints
| Restaurant | Address | Printed price | Check before going |
|---|---|---|---|
| Da Vinci Pizzeria | 6514 18th Ave | Round pie $22.00; slice $3.50 | No hours printed; some items “Out of stock” |
| Tommaso | 6916 18th Ave | Chicken parmigiana 24, no dollar sign | Every price; no Monday line |
| L&B Spumoni Gardens | 2725 86th St | Round pie $24.00; chicken entrées $25.95 | No event capacity posted |
| Gargiulo’s (Coney Island) | 2911 West 15th St | Chicken Parmigiana $26.50 | Closed Tuesday |
Why is a Coney Island restaurant in a Bensonhurst guide?
Each of the four has an official site readable as text, with posted hours or a priced menu. Tommaso, L&B and Da Vinci use the word Bensonhurst on their own pages. Gargiulo’s contact page gives Coney Island, so it is a labeled outlier and the oldest-dated benchmark. The Bensonhurst headings follow the search phrase, not an official boundary. These are editorial picks, not a taste test, and the table is a sort rather than a ranking. Restaurants whose sites could not be read are left out, which says nothing about their food.
Where can you eat on 18th Avenue in Bensonhurst?
Two of the four print an 18th Avenue address: Da Vinci at 6514 and Tommaso at 6916.
Da Vinci Pizzeria: pies, slices and a 1966 start
Da Vinci’s Our Story page says the family has owned and operated it “since 1966”. It adds that the menu highlights Neapolitan and Sicilian pies “alongside comforting classics like baked ziti and chicken parm”, but the online-ordering menu read for this guide lists neither dish. It shows a Sicilian Square Pie at $34.00, a Napoletana Round Pie at $22.00, a Pepperoni Pizza at $27.00, slices at $3.50, a Calzone at $8.00 and a Gluten Free Pizza at $15.50; anyone avoiding gluten should confirm with the restaurant. That menu list tagged its items “Out of stock” when read, and no opening hours appear in readable text, so call (718) 232-5855 first.
Tommaso: “Est. 1972” and a move to 18th Avenue
Tommaso’s home page, which carries a 2026 footer, presents the restaurant as open at 6916 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, calls it “Est. 1972” and gives hours of Tuesday to Saturday 12 to 10pm and Sunday 12 to 9pm, with no Monday line. The site says the restaurant began at 1464 86th Street and that the doors at the original location “eventually closed”; it does not date the move.
Reservations are “warmly encouraged” by form or by phone at (718) 484-0028, and the form says a request is “not a confirmed booking”. Party-size choices run to 12, then “More than 12”, and the page lists “Full buyouts welcome” with no room size or price.
The menu page loads its dishes from a data file that prints bare figures with no currency symbol: 24 beside Chicken Parmigiana, 28 beside Veal Parmigiana and 22 beside Eggplant Parmigiana, each “served with spaghetti”. Treat those as figures to confirm, not dollar prices.
What does L&B Spumoni Gardens charge, and when is it open?
L&B’s hours page lists Monday to Sunday, 11:00 AM to 11:30 PM, and its 86th Street page describes a “Brooklyn Tradition Since 1939” open for indoor and outdoor dining. As of October 2026 its in-house menu prints dollar prices throughout:
- Pizza: the “World Famous L&B Sicilian Pie” is $35.00, a Round Pie $24.00 and a Slice $4.50.
- Pasta: Marinara Sauce is $15.95 and Broccoli Rabe and Sausage $24.95. Twelve of the 13 sauces on the Pastas list are under 20 dollars.
- Entrées: Chicken Entrées are $25.95 and Veal Entrées $29.95, with Parmigiana on both lists, served with potato croquette and mixed vegetables or a side of pasta in marinara sauce.
- Other: a Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana hero is $16.95.
Gluten Free Pasta costs an additional $5.95; anyone avoiding gluten or an allergen should confirm with the restaurant. For events the site describes a “spacious indoor dining room and outdoor patio” but posts no capacity or price.
Best for a large party: Gargiulo’s in Coney Island
Gargiulo’s dates itself to 1907 and gives its address as 2911 West 15th Street, Coney Island. As of October 2026 its home page lists Tuesday as closed and noon openings otherwise, with closes at 9:30pm on Monday, Wednesday and Thursday, 10:30pm on Friday and Saturday and 9:00pm on Sunday. Its menu page labels one PDF “Dinner Menu”, and that PDF lists Chicken Parmigiana at $26.50 and Veal Parmigiana at $28.50, pasta from $23.00, and “20% Gratuity will be added for tables of 12 or more people”. The contact page adds “Proper Attire Required” under Reservations.
It is the only one of the four sites to publish room sizes, from a Board Room for “Up to 25 Guests” to a Marble Room for “Up to 400 Guests”, without saying whether they are seated or standing. Its mains, set against five Manhattan kitchens, are in the price-band comparison of Italian-American menus.
Who is open on a Monday or a Tuesday?
Of the four, only Gargiulo’s lists Tuesday as closed, and it is in Coney Island. Monday is less clear, as of October 2026: two of the four print no Monday hours.
| Day | Tommaso | L&B | Gargiulo’s | Da Vinci |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monday | Not listed | 11:00 AM to 11:30 PM | 12:00 PM to 9:30 PM | Not printed |
| Tuesday | 12 to 10pm | 11:00 AM to 11:30 PM | Closed | Not printed |
| Sunday | 12 to 9pm | 11:00 AM to 11:30 PM | 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM | Not printed |
L&B opens at 11:00 AM, an hour before Tommaso and Gargiulo’s, and closes at 11:30 PM, at least an hour after either on every night they share.
Which Bensonhurst names closed or were left out?
- Europa Pizzeria: its home page calls it a Bensonhurst staple “since 2001” and carries a notice reading “we have made the difficult decision to permanently close our business”.
- Savelli: its home page gives the location as 195 Smith Street, Brooklyn, so it is not covered here.
- Il Colosseo: its site returned no readable text, so its hours and prices could not be checked.
L&B or Gargiulo’s: how far apart are the prices?
Three dishes appear on both printed menus, as of October 2026:
| Dish | L&B (86th Street) | Gargiulo’s (Coney Island) | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken parmigiana entrée | $25.95 | $26.50 | L&B 55 cents lower |
| Veal parmigiana entrée | $29.95 | $28.50 | L&B 1.45 dollars higher |
| Tomato-sauce pasta | $15.95, Marinara Sauce | $23.00, Spaghettini Tomato Sauce | L&B 7.05 dollars lower |
L&B states what comes with its entrées and Gargiulo’s PDF does not, so the chicken gap is not like for like. Eggplant parmigiana is left out: Gargiulo’s PDF prints that figure without a dollar sign, and L&B’s page shows both $19.95 and $18.95 beside it. Against Da Vinci, L&B’s $4.50 slice is 1 dollar above $3.50 and its $24.00 round pie 2 dollars above $22.00; neither page prints sizes, so those compare listings, not equal pizzas.
The printed numbers point to a rule. For pasta, or a table on any day of the week, L&B. For veal parmigiana or a party with posted room sizes, Gargiulo’s. For the lower listed slice price, Da Vinci. For a sit-down room where price comes second, Tommaso, after a call. For another Brooklyn strip, see Bay Ridge Italian restaurants; a sister publication’s Brooklyn shortlist covers Lilia, Misi, Al Di La, Frankies 457 and Roberta’s.
Frequently asked questions
Is Tommaso still open, and where is it now?
Tommaso’s own site presents it as open, as of October 2026, at 6916 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, with hours of Tuesday to Saturday 12 to 10pm and Sunday 12 to 9pm. It says its original location at 1464 86th Street closed, so call (718) 484-0028 before relying on an older address.
Which Bensonhurst Italian restaurants are closed on Tuesdays?
Of the four in this guide, only Gargiulo’s lists Tuesday as closed, and it is in Coney Island rather than Bensonhurst. Tommaso and L&B Spumoni Gardens list Tuesday hours; Da Vinci Pizzeria prints none.
How much is chicken parmigiana at Bensonhurst Italian restaurants?
As of October 2026, L&B Spumoni Gardens lists chicken entrées, Parmigiana among the preparations, at $25.95, and Gargiulo’s in Coney Island lists Chicken Parmigiana at $26.50. Tommaso’s menu data prints 24 beside Chicken Parmigiana with no dollar sign, so confirm that figure by phone at (718) 484-0028 before counting on it.
What is the oldest Italian restaurant in Brooklyn?
This guide cannot name one for the whole borough. Among the four, Gargiulo’s prints the earliest date, “since 1907”, followed by L&B’s “Since 1939”, Da Vinci’s “since 1966” and Tommaso’s “Est. 1972”. Those are the restaurants’ own claims; for Manhattan rooms that state founding years, see the guide to the oldest Italian restaurants in NYC.


