The Red Sauce IndexRankings Issue · July 2026
11

Staten Island Pizza: Hours, Prices and Pie Styles Compared

Tony Marchetti · November 11, 2026 · 8 min read

Snapshot answerStaten Island pizza compared on each shop's own pages: Joe & Pat's, Bravo, Tony's Brick Oven, Goodfella's and Mimmo's, with pie prices, sizes, hours and styles.

A 16-inch cheese pie costs $18 at Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, the lowest of the three Staten Island pizzerias here that print one, against $20.75+ at Tony’s Brick Oven and $29 for the brick-oven pizza at Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza. Bravo Pizza & Sports Bar is the only one of the five pizzerias compared that is open past 11pm, closing at 1:00 AM on Friday and Saturday. Prices, hours and pie styles below come from each pizzeria’s own website or ordering page, checked in October 2026.

How do Staten Island pizzerias compare on price and closing time?

These five Staten Island pizzerias publish an address, hours and pie prices on their own sites or ordering pages. Shops whose sites print too little are left out, which says nothing about quality, and this is a comparison of published figures, not a taste test. Prices are as printed, with sizes only where a page gives them.

Pizzeria Address Cheese or Regular pie, as printed Sicilian or square pie, as printed Friday and Saturday close
Joe & Pat’s 1758 Victory Blvd 14" $15; 16" $18 14" $19; 16" $23; Grandma Sicilian-Style $25 11pm
Bravo Pizza & Sports Bar 413 New Dorp Lane Regular Medium $16.00; Regular Large $21.00 Sicilian $21.00; Grandma $23.00 1:00 AM
Tony’s Brick Oven 1140 Bay Street 14" $18.95+; 16" $20.75+; 18" $22.00+ Sicilian 16" $29.00+ 10:30pm
Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza 4029 Hylan Blvd 12" $18.00; 16" $29.00 (brick-oven pizza, base price) None listed 11pm
Mimmo’s Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria 15 Giffords Lane Regular Cheese $12.00, no size printed Sicilian $25.00; Grandma’s $23.00 10pm

Tony’s ordering page prints a plus sign after its item prices and does not say what it covers, so confirm the final figure. Bravo’s menu page says it is the online ordering menu, and Bravo prints “Regular” without the word cheese. Mimmo’s prices come from an ordering page in its name (ordermimmosbrickovenpizza.com), because the menu pages on its main site print no prices in text, so confirm them with the restaurant.

How old is each pizzeria, by its own account?

Joe & Pat’s makes the oldest claim of the five: its home page says it has been serving pizza and Italian dishes since 1960. Bravo says the family has made pizza since 1985, though its New Dorp Lane room opened in 2020. Goodfella’s About page reads “Established 1992 at 1718 Hylan Blvd,” while its location block gives 4029 Hylan Boulevard, so confirm the address. Tony’s says it has welcomed Staten Island neighbors since 1997, and Mimmo’s Brick Oven says it was “born back in 2016.”

Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern at 524 Port Richmond Ave. prints no founding year on the pages read, so no opening date is given for it here.

What does a pie cost by size, by the slice and on special?

At 14 inches, Joe & Pat’s cheese pie is $15 against Tony’s $18.95+. At 16 inches it is $18 against $20.75+, and Goodfella’s prints $29 for its 16-inch brick-oven pizza. Tony’s prints slice counts, so its 16-inch round cheese pie (8 slices) starts near 2.59 dollars a slice, below the $3.60+ it lists for a single Regular Slice.

By the slice, Bravo lists Regular at $2.53, Sicilian at $3.67 and Grandma at $4.13, and Tony’s lists Regular and Sicilian at $3.60+ and Grandpa at $3.75+. Joe & Pat’s prints no slice prices.

The lowest numbers are deals. Mimmo’s lists a Regular Large Cheese Pie at $9.99 as a Monday and Tuesday pick-up special; its page does not say what size the $12.00 Regular Cheese Pizza is, so the two cannot be compared. Bravo lists a Regular Large pie at $10.00 every day, maximum two per order, 11 dollars below its own $21.00 Regular Large. Joe & Pat’s lists a large cheese pie at $13.00 plus tax Monday to Wednesday, pick-up and cash only; its pages carry a 2017 copyright line, so confirm by phone at 718-981-0887. For bar pies, Bravo’s 10-inch Bar Pie Regular is $12.00 and its happy hour (every day, 4:00 PM to 7:00 PM) lists a $6 Bar Pie, while Goodfella’s lists $10 Bar Pies Monday through Friday, 12 pm to 6 pm, only at the bar.

Goodfella’s pages disagree: goodfellas.com prints 12" Small $18.00 and 16" Large $29.00, but a separate ordering page in its name (goodfellashylan.com) lists a Brick Oven Cheese Pizza at $13.00 and a Large Brick Oven Pizza at $21.00, with no inch sizes. Call (718)-987-2422 before relying on either.

What do Sicilian, grandma and brick oven mean on these menus?

The labels are the pizzerias’ own, and they do not line up. Joe & Pat’s sells “Sicilian-Style” and “Grandma Sicilian-Style” pies and calls its pizza “thin crust.” Tony’s lists a Grandpa Pizza “on a thin Sicilian Crust,” while Mimmo’s describes its Grandpa’s as an “Original thick crust pizza” and its Grandma’s as a “Thin square pizza with thick tomato sauce & mozzarella.” Bravo adds Marinara Sicilian, Chicago Style and a Stuffed Pizza category to its Regular, Sicilian and Grandma pies.

“Brick oven” is a label too. Goodfella’s says it cooks “in a real wood fired brick oven at 800 degrees,” and its goodfellashylan.com ordering page lists an NY Style Pizza baked in a wood-fired brick oven. Mimmo’s heads its round pies “Wood-Fired Brick Oven Pizza,” including a Margarita at $15.00, and Tony’s Brick Oven Pizza section starts with a Margherita at $25.75+. A name does not settle crust thickness, so read the description.

Who is open past 10pm, and who closes early?

Bravo is the outlier: 11 AM to 1 AM every day, with its full menu until 11 PM and an Extended Hours menu after that, on which the Regular Large pie is tagged After 11 PM. Joe & Pat’s and Goodfella’s both close at 10pm Sunday to Thursday and 11pm Friday and Saturday, with Goodfella’s opening at 11:30 AM. Tony’s closes at 9:30 PM Monday to Thursday and 10:30 PM Friday and Saturday, and is closed Sunday. Sunday through Thursday, only Bravo is open past 10pm.

Mimmo’s is the least consistent. Its main site has the pizzeria open to 10pm daily, from noon on Sunday, while its ordering page shows 11:00 AM-9:30 PM. Its dining room hours also conflict: the home page has Sunday from 12pm, the menu page 5pm every day. The main-site pages carry a 2020 copyright line, so call before a late order.

Do Staten Island pizzerias also serve full Italian dinners?

All five list pasta and entrees. Goodfella’s Entrees section lists Chicken Parm at $24.00, Bravo’s Pasta and Entrees section lists Chicken Parmigiana at $20.95, and Tony’s menu page lists baked ziti, lasagna, stuffed shells and manicotti. Mimmo’s lists pasta, entree and dining room menus. Joe & Pat’s dinner prices are in the Staten Island Italian restaurant guide, and chicken parm in NYC prices the same dish in Manhattan.

What about Denino’s, Royal Pizza and Mimmo’s Pizza Shoppe?

Three more Staten Island shops have sites that print too little to join the table.

  • Denino’s: 718-442-9401. Its home page calls the pizza “The King Of NY Style Thin Crust Pizza,” but its menu page shows placeholder text (“This Is Your Dish Name”) and no hours appear.
  • Royal Pizza: 1757 Arthur Kill Rd. Its ordering page lists a Plain Slice at $3.00, a Sicilian Slice at $3.00 and a Grandma Slice at $3.75, and a Cheese Pizza at $17.99 with no size. No weekly schedule appears in the page text.
  • Mimmo’s Pizza Shoppe: 1547 Arthur Kill Rd, 718.865.1470. Its menu page shows no readable text and no hours appear. Its home page lists a $29.99 family special of two large cheese pies, garlic knots and a 2 liter soda under a “Grand Opening Specials” label.

Which pizzeria fits which order?

  • Latest pie: Bravo, open to 1 AM, with its Regular Large and other pies on the after-11-PM list.
  • Lowest cheese pie with a printed inch size: Joe & Pat’s, $15 at 14 inches and $18 at 16.
  • Lowest large-pie deal: Mimmo’s at $9.99 (Monday and Tuesday, pick-up only) or Bravo at $10.00 (every day, two per order), against Joe & Pat’s $13.00 plus tax Monday to Wednesday.
  • A 16-inch Sicilian: Joe & Pat’s at $23 versus Tony’s at $29.00+, the only two of the five that print one.
  • Sunday: every pizzeria in the table except Tony’s, with Mimmo’s opening at noon.

For a pasta night rather than a pie, nine NYC Italian restaurants that print a pasta main under $20, Joe & Pat’s among them, are sorted by price.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I find brick oven pizza on Staten Island?

Three of the five pizzerias compared carry “brick oven” in their names: Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza at 4029 Hylan Blvd, Mimmo’s Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria at 15 Giffords Lane and Tony’s Brick Oven at 1140 Bay Street. Goodfella’s says it cooks in a wood fired brick oven at 800 degrees. These are each shop’s own descriptions, not a ranking.

How much is a pie at a Staten Island pizzeria?

As printed in October 2026, a 16-inch cheese pie is $18 at Joe & Pat’s and $20.75+ at Tony’s Brick Oven. Bravo prints a Regular Medium at $16.00 and a Regular Large at $21.00 without inch sizes, plus a $10.00 large regular pie special every day.

Which Staten Island pizzerias are open late?

As of October 2026, Bravo Pizza & Sports Bar is open 11 AM to 1 AM daily, with a late menu after 11 PM. Joe & Pat’s and Goodfella’s close at 11pm on Friday and Saturday, Tony’s at 10:30pm and Mimmo’s pizzeria at 10pm per its main site, though its ordering page shows 9:30 PM.

Which Staten Island pizzerias have been open the longest?

By each shop’s own account, Joe & Pat’s has been serving pizza and Italian dishes since 1960, the oldest claim of the five. Goodfella’s says 1992, Tony’s Brick Oven 1997 and Mimmo’s Brick Oven 2016, while Bravo says its family has made pizza since 1985 and its New Dorp Lane room opened in 2020.

More ranked guides

3 guides · Updated 11.2026 · Newest first
The next issue

Get the next ranking before the group chat does

One email when a new ranked guide publishes — the scores, the table, and the booking window that matters. Nothing else.

No spam · unsubscribe anytime · rankings only