Italian Neighborhoods in NYC: Staten Island to the Bronx
Tony Marchetti · November 18, 2026 · 8 min read
Across eight Italian neighborhoods in NYC, each read through one anchor restaurant’s menu, a chicken parm runs from $19 at Ann & Tony’s at 2407 Arthur Avenue in the Bronx to $29.95 at Lenny’s Clam Bar at 161-03 Cross Bay Boulevard in Howard Beach. The other six are Little Italy on Mulberry Street, Morris Park in the Bronx, Staten Island, Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst and Coney Island. Hours, prices and policies below come from each restaurant’s own website, checked in October 2026.
One anchor restaurant per neighborhood
| Neighborhood and anchor | Own founding line | Closed day | Chicken parm | Group route listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Little Italy: Da Nico, 164 Mulberry St | “since 1993” | None | $29 | Requests for parties of 8 or more |
| Arthur Avenue: Ann & Tony’s, 2407 Arthur Ave | “since 1927” | Monday | $19 | Small private room, by phone |
| Morris Park: Emilio’s of Morris Park, 1051 Morris Park Ave | “since 1989” | None | $20.95 | Catering |
| Staten Island: Joe & Pat’s, 1758 Victory Blvd | “since 1960” | None | $24 | Catering trays |
| Bay Ridge: Gino’s Restaurant, 7414 Fifth Ave | “Established 1964” | Monday | $26 | Family style, parties of 10-20 |
| Bensonhurst: L&B Spumoni Gardens, 2725 86th St | “Since 1939” | None | $25.95 | Events in dining room and patio |
| Coney Island: Gargiulo’s, 2911 West 15th St | “since 1907” | Tuesday | $26.50 | Eight rooms, “Up to 25 Guests” to “Up to 400 Guests” |
| Howard Beach: Lenny’s Clam Bar, 161-03 Cross Bay Blvd | “Opened in 1974” | None | $29.95 | Three rooms, 40 to 65 guests |
Prices are as listed, as of October 2026; confirm tax and gratuity with the restaurant. On the pages read, Gino’s prints its year only on its October lunch prix fixe PDF.
How were these neighborhoods compared?
Each neighborhood has one anchor, taken from this site’s guide to that area because its own pages state a founding year, list weekly hours, print a dollar price for chicken parmigiana and name a way to book a group. The Arthur Avenue row follows this site’s Arthur Avenue guide, which also covers Roberto’s at 603 Crescent Avenue and Antonio’s Trattoria at 2370 Belmont Avenue. This guide makes no census, neighborhood-history or “largest community” claims, because none was checked against an official source. These are editorial picks, not a taste test. Joe & Pat’s pages carry a 2017 copyright line, so read its prices as listed, not confirmed. Counts use the hours pages of 29 restaurants, the anchors included: a sample, not every restaurant in each neighborhood. A restaurant counts as closed on a day only where its page prints “Closed” for it.
Is there still a Little Italy in NYC?
Restaurants on Mulberry Street still use the name for themselves. Il Cortile, at 125 Mulberry Street, calls itself a “Little Italy neighborhood staple for over 40 years” and says it has been “family owned and operated since 1975”. Umberto’s Clam House at 132 Mulberry Street says Umberto Ianniello opened it on Mulberry Street in 1972, and Da Nico says “since 1993”. All three list Monday hours. The Little Italy guide has the full list.
The Bronx uses it too. Emilia’s puts itself in the “heart of Little Italy” in the Bronx, and the Bronx page of Zero Otto Nove is headed “The Little Italy of the Bronx”. The Arthur Avenue guide sorts that street by opening days.
Which other Bronx streets have Italian restaurants?
Morris Park Avenue is one. Emilio’s opens at 10 AM and closes at 11 PM Monday through Thursday, and says it has served Morris Park and beyond “since 1989”. Addeo’s of the Bronx, at 1056 Morris Park Ave, lists 11am to 10pm Monday to Saturday but gives Sunday as 12 to 10pm on its home page and 12:00 to 9:00pm on its Reservations page. The Grand Concourse is another: Giovanni at 579 Grand Concourse says “Established in 1992” and lists 11:00AM to 10:00PM seven days a week. More are in the Bronx guide beyond Arthur Avenue.
Does Staten Island have a named Italian neighborhood?
No Staten Island site read here defines one, but three restaurants name their own. Tutto Apposto at 31 Page Ave says “Tottenville” on its menu page and “Best Italian Restaurant in Richmond Valley” on its home page. Corrado’s Cucina places itself “in the Great Kills area”, and La Fontana says its family has served “Staten Island in Oakwood since 1983”. The anchor, Joe & Pat’s, gives a street address and “since 1960”; the Staten Island guide has menus and party rooms.
What is the Italian section of Brooklyn known for?
None of the Brooklyn sites read for this guide names an “Italian section”, so this answer is limited to what their restaurants print. In Bay Ridge, five of the seven restaurants checked print Third Avenue addresses, from Peppino’s at 7708 3rd Ave to Brooklyn Roots at 8602 3rd Ave; Gino’s is on Fifth Avenue and the seventh on 4th Avenue. The Bay Ridge guide compares them.
In Bensonhurst, L&B says it serves “iconic Sicilian square pizza” and homemade spumoni, and Tommaso at 6916 18th Ave calls itself “Est. 1972” while saying its original location closed. Gargiulo’s, in Coney Island, describes “authentic Neapolitan Italian cuisine”. The Bensonhurst guide covers all three, and a sister publication’s Brooklyn shortlist covers rooms outside these strips.
What about Howard Beach in Queens?
In this sample, all four restaurants sit on one road: each prints a Cross Bay or Crossbay Boulevard address, from Matteo’s at 155-10 to Vetro at 164-49. The Howard Beach guide lists their hours and group rooms.
Which Italian neighborhood in NYC has the cheapest dinner?
On the eight anchors’ chicken parm, lowest to highest: Arthur Avenue $19, Morris Park $20.95, Staten Island $24, Bensonhurst $25.95, Bay Ridge $26, Coney Island $26.50, Little Italy $29 and Howard Beach $29.95. The gap from first to last is 10.95 dollars (29.95 minus 19).
Three limits apply. First, it ranks eight menus, not eight neighborhoods: Addeo’s in Morris Park lists chicken parmigiana at $25 against Emilio’s $20.95, Tutto Apposto on Staten Island $29.00 against Joe & Pat’s $24, and Luliano’s in Bay Ridge $23 against Gino’s $26, though Ann & Tony’s $19 is still the lowest in this guide. Second, the plates differ: Ann & Tony’s comes with pasta marinara, Emilio’s with pasta, salad or potato croquette, and Lenny’s with vegetables and potatoes. Third, L&B’s $25.95 is for chicken entrées, Parmigiana first among them. The Howard Beach guide compares the other restaurants on Cross Bay Boulevard; for pasta rather than cutlets, see pasta under 20 dollars.
Which neighborhood handles a big group?
All eight anchors name a route for a group, but only two print room sizes. Gargiulo’s lists eight rooms, from a Board Room for “Up to 25 Guests” to a Marble Room for “Up to 400 Guests”. Lenny’s names three party rooms, for up to 40, 60 and 65 people, and prices Party Menu 1 at $39.95 per person plus an administrative fee and sales tax.
Beyond the anchors, Il Cortile’s Garden Room holds up to 80 guests. Giovanni puts its limit at 200 when the GBar next door is included, and Vetro says its private rooms “take sixty to a hundred and fifty guests”. On Staten Island, Tutto Apposto’s Main Room seats 85 and La Fontana’s party rooms take 10 to 80 guests. Per-head family-style prices are in the family-style guide.
Which Italian neighborhood is hardest on a Monday?
Of the 29 restaurants counted, 11 list Monday as closed and 5 list Tuesday. By share, the Arthur Avenue area is the hardest to plan (3 of 5), and by count Bay Ridge is (4 of 7), as of October 2026.
| Neighborhood | Counted | Closed Monday | Which |
|---|---|---|---|
| Little Italy | 3 | 0 | None |
| Arthur Avenue area | 5 | 3 | Ann & Tony’s, Zero Otto Nove, Roberto’s |
| Morris Park | 2 | 0 | None |
| Staten Island | 6 | 3 | Tutto Apposto, Corrado’s, Eat Italian |
| Bay Ridge | 7 | 4 | Gino’s, Luliano’s, Brooklyn Roots, Peppino’s |
| Bensonhurst and Coney Island | 2 | 0 | None |
| Howard Beach | 4 | 1 | Vetro |
| All | 29 | 11 |
The other 18 list Monday hours. Tuesday closures are Emilia’s on Arthur Avenue, Trattoria Oliveto on Staten Island, Terina and Peppino’s in Bay Ridge, and Gargiulo’s in Coney Island. Terina’s page prints its days and times in separate blocks, so confirm its Monday and Tuesday lines. Three pages are left out of the count: Don Roberto’s on Staten Island lists Monday-to-Thursday kitchen hours and also says “Closed Monday”, Tommaso lists no Monday line, and Giovanni’s Grand Concourse address fits neither Bronx row.
Which neighborhood fits which night?
- A Monday: Little Italy, Morris Park, Bensonhurst or Coney Island, where none of the 7 restaurants counted is closed, or Howard Beach, where 3 of 4 are open. Check hours first on Arthur Avenue, Staten Island and Bay Ridge (10 of 18 close).
- A party past 85: Gargiulo’s (rooms up to 400), Giovanni (up to 200) or Vetro (private rooms up to 150). No other capacity quoted in this guide is above 85.
- A Tuesday: skip the five named above as closed.
Frequently asked questions
Little Italy or Arthur Avenue: which is cheaper, and which is open on Mondays?
Ann & Tony’s on Arthur Avenue lists chicken parmigiana at $19 and Da Nico on Mulberry Street at $29, a difference of 10 dollars. Monday reverses that: three of the five Arthur Avenue-area restaurants counted are closed Mondays, while all three Little Italy restaurants counted list Monday hours, as of October 2026.
Which Italian restaurants in NYC are closed on Mondays?
Of 29 restaurants whose own pages were read here, 11 list Monday as closed: 3 of 5 in the Arthur Avenue area, 4 of 7 in Bay Ridge, 3 of 6 on Staten Island and 1 of 4 in Howard Beach. None of the Little Italy, Morris Park, Bensonhurst or Coney Island restaurants counted does. Confirm before traveling.
Which NYC Italian neighborhood has the oldest restaurant?
Among the eight anchors, Gargiulo’s in Coney Island states the earliest year, “since 1907”, followed by Ann & Tony’s on Arthur Avenue (“since 1927”) and L&B Spumoni Gardens in Bensonhurst (“Since 1939”). These are the restaurants’ own statements; other restaurants named here were not compared on founding dates.


