The Red Sauce IndexRankings Issue · July 2026
08

Cheap Italian Restaurants NYC: Pasta Under $20, Verified

Tony Marchetti · November 8, 2026 · 8 min read

Snapshot answerCheap Italian restaurants NYC with a pasta main under $20 on the menu: John's, Bigoi Venezia, Joe & Pat's, Emilio's and five more, checked October 2026.

Pasta mains under $20 are printed on the dinner or all-day menus of nine New York Italian restaurants, among them John’s of 12th Street and Bigoi Venezia in Manhattan, Joe & Pat’s on Staten Island and Emilio’s of Morris Park in the Bronx. The lowest counted price is $11.95 for John’s Butter Sauce pasta, and the median of the nine restaurants’ lowest prices is 16.95 dollars. Hours, prices and policies below come from each restaurant’s own website, checked in October 2026.

Which restaurants print a pasta main under $20, lowest price first?

Rows run from the lowest qualifying price to the highest. Prices are menu prices as printed, before tax and tip; a dollar sign marks a printed price, and a figure written out in dollars is this guide’s arithmetic.

Restaurant Address Lowest pasta main Pastas under $20 Menu read and caveat
John’s of 12th Street 302 East 12th Street, Manhattan $11.95 Butter Sauce 7 of 12 Traditional menu; open daily from 4PM
Don Giovanni 358 West 44th Street and 214 10th Avenue, Manhattan $14.00 garlic and oil, or lemon and butter 4 of 20 Single menu page for both rooms; footer cites a $45.00 per-person minimum
Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria & Restaurant 1758 Victory Boulevard, Staten Island $14 Stuffed Manicotti 21 of 28 Pasta page; open daily; page carries a 2017 copyright line
Bigoi Venezia 1415 Second Avenue, Manhattan $15.70 Al Pomodoro 12 of 12 Menu page
Emilio’s of Morris Park 1051 Morris Park Avenue, Bronx $16.95 Tomato Sauce 10 of 15 Main Menu, with salad and bread
Max SoHa 1274 Amsterdam Avenue, Manhattan $18.95 Gnocchi alla Sorrentina 3 of 12 Dinner tab, daily 4pm to 10:30pm
Trapizzino 144 Orchard Street, Manhattan $19 Cacio e Pepe 1 of 3 Dinner tab
SoleLuna 40-01 Queens Boulevard, Sunnyside, Queens $19.50, three pastas 3 of 6 Menu served from 12pm
Gino’s Restaurant 7414 Fifth Avenue, Brooklyn $19.95 Penne Vodka and Lasagna 2 of 14 Daily Menu tab

What counts as under $20 in this guide?

A restaurant qualifies when its own website prints a full-size pasta at $19.95 or less on a dinner menu, or on a menu with no meal split, in readable text. Half orders, sides, add-ons, happy-hour plates, lunch-only tabs, prix fixe menus and prices printed without a dollar sign do not count. Four lines are left out of the counts: Bigoi’s Plain Pasta at $10.50, which has no sauce; Joe & Pat’s Fried Ravioli at $13, a fried item rather than a sauced plate; and Gino’s Ravioli at $14.95 and Manicotti at $15.95, which cost less than the $16.95 the same page charges for a half order of pasta, so the portion is unclear. Counting all four would move the lowest price to 10.50 dollars and the median to 14.95 dollars.

These are editorial picks against posted prices, not a taste test. Restaurants whose own sites would not load in October 2026 are left out, which says nothing about their prices.

What is the cheapest pasta in NYC?

No guide can certify a citywide cheapest, but among the menus read for this one, John’s Butter Sauce at $11.95 is the lowest sauced pasta, with its Tomato Sauce at $13.95 next. The other restaurants’ lowest plates start at Don Giovanni’s $14.00 spaghetti or penne with garlic and oil and Joe & Pat’s $14 Stuffed Manicotti. Max SoHa’s happy-hour menu prints three pastas at $12, Monday to Thursday from 4 to 6pm, but the page does not say how large they are, so they stay out.

Across the nine restaurants the lowest prices span 8.00 dollars, from 11.95 to 19.95, and the median is 16.95 dollars, which is Emilio’s Tomato Sauce. La Superlativa, a sister publication, compares eight Manhattan menus in why pasta costs so much in NYC.

Extras change the answer. At John’s, Marinara at $14.95 plus chicken at $8.00 comes to 22.95 dollars. At Joe & Pat’s, a $15 spaghetti with a $5 meatball comes to exactly 20 dollars, which is not under $20. Sauce-only pasta is the version that clears the line.

Where should you eat when the check matters?

Best for a Manhattan dinner: John’s, Max SoHa and Trapizzino

John’s is open daily, Sunday to Wednesday 4-10PM and Thursday to Saturday 4-10:30PM. Its Meat Sauce, Homemade Manicotti and Garlic, Oil & Anchovies are each $19.95, and Carbonara is $24.95. Trapizzino qualifies on one dish: Cacio e Pepe at $19, since Pesto at $20 sits on the line rather than under it and Rigatoni Al Ragu is $21. The pages read list no hours for Trapizzino, so call (212) 475-2555 before going.

Best for a tight price range: Bigoi Venezia

Bigoi prints twelve sauced pastas, the only one of the nine menus with none at $20 or more: eleven at $16.90 and Al Pomodoro at $15.70. The pages read give no daily hours, so call (917)-262-0680 before a trip.

Best outside Manhattan: Emilio’s, Joe & Pat’s, SoleLuna and Gino’s

Emilio’s pastas are “Served with a salad & bread”, so its $16.95 Tomato Sauce plate includes more than pasta, and Friday and Saturday hours run to 12 AM. Joe & Pat’s has the longest counted pasta list of the nine, at 28 lines. Its pasta page carries a 2017 copyright line, so confirm prices at 718-981-0887. Party menus and dinner prices elsewhere on the island are in the Staten Island Italian restaurant guide.

SoleLuna’s three $19.50 pastas and Gino’s two $19.95 plates clear the line narrowly, and Gino’s page lists Monday as closed.

Check the fine print: Don Giovanni

Don Giovanni posts a single menu covering both of its rooms, and four of the 20 pastas on its Pasta list are under $20. A footer line on its page reads “On rush hour and high season time, subject to min of $45.00 per person”, and it adds an 18% gratuity for in-house parties of 4 or more. The page does not say which room or hours the minimum covers, so call 212.581.4939 (West 44th Street) or 212.242.9054 (10th Avenue) before building a budget around the $14.00 plates.

Which menus look cheap but fail the test?

Gargiulo’s dinner menu starts its pastas at $23.00 for Spaghettini with tomato sauce, and Fratelli in the Bronx starts its list at $22.95 for Spaghetti Garlic & Oil. For Gargiulo’s main courses next to five other kitchens, see the price-band report on Italian-American restaurants.

Two Manhattan menus show how much the meal matters. Ferdi starts its Dinner tab pastas at $24.00, while its Lunch tab prints Lasagna, Gnocchi alla Sorrentina, Fettucine Bolognese and Spaghetti Carbonara at $19.95. That tab states no days, and Ferdi’s home page shows noon openings only on Saturday and Sunday, when its brunch menu runs 12:00 pm to 4:00 pm. Pasta Eater, at 9 East 17th Street, prints eight pastas at $15.00 on its Lunch tab and starts its Dinner tab at $24.00, with no lunch days or end time printed. Both lunch lists stay out of the count until a call confirms when lunch is served.

San Marzano, at 117 2nd Avenue, prints pasta sauces in its dinner menu PDF as 15, with Wild Boar Ragù at 17, and no dollar signs. Those are figures to confirm, not dollars, and they are not counted.

Do any set menus come in under the line?

None of the set menus read here is under $20, and the cheapest are lunch or early-afternoon offers. Ferdi’s three-course prix fixe is $30.00 per guest, available only 2:00 to 5:30pm on Fridays and Saturdays (its home page opens Friday at 3:00 PM, so confirm the Friday start), and its Italian Family Style Lunch Option is $26 per guest, with no days or times stated. Olio e Più, at 3 Greenwich Avenue, lists a $29 lunch prix fixe, Monday to Friday 11am to 4pm. Its main-course choices include Spaghetti alla Carbonara, which is also $29 on its lunch menu, so the starter comes free with that main.

San Marzano takes reservations for parties of four or more, and every reservation carries a prix fixe: $58 per guest for dinner or $34 for brunch, plus tax and 20% gratuity. For group set menus compared by cost per head, see family-style Italian restaurants in NYC.

Frequently asked questions

Are there Italian restaurants in NYC with pasta under $20?

Yes. As of October 2026, nine restaurants read for this guide print a pasta main under $20 on a dinner or all-day menu. Bigoi Venezia has every sauced pasta between $15.70 and $16.90, John’s of 12th Street has seven pastas from $11.95, and Emilio’s of Morris Park has ten from $16.95, served with salad and bread.

Is there a cheap prix fixe Italian dinner in NYC?

No set menu read for this guide is under $20. The lowest is Ferdi’s Italian Family Style Lunch Option at $26 per guest, on a page that states no days or times, and the next is Olio e Più’s $29 lunch prix fixe, Monday to Friday 11am to 4pm. San Marzano’s dinner prix fixe, required for a reservation, is $58 per guest.

Is bottomless pasta available in NYC?

None of the menus read for this guide lists bottomless or unlimited pasta. The bottomless offers on those pages are drinks: San Marzano’s $34 brunch adds bottomless mimosas and drip coffee to one main course, and Ferdi’s brunch lists bottomless spritzes, Espresso Martinis and Bellinis for $19.95 per guest with a food purchase.

Does adding chicken or a meatball keep a pasta under $20?

Usually not. As of October 2026, John’s Marinara at $14.95 plus chicken at $8.00 comes to 22.95 dollars, and Emilio’s Tomato Sauce at $16.95 plus chicken at $9.95 comes to 26.90 dollars. Joe & Pat’s $15 spaghetti plus its $5 meatball reaches exactly 20 dollars, which does not count as under $20. Only the sauce-only plates clear the line.

More ranked guides

3 guides · Updated 11.2026 · Newest first
The next issue

Get the next ranking before the group chat does

One email when a new ranked guide publishes — the scores, the table, and the booking window that matters. Nothing else.

No spam · unsubscribe anytime · rankings only